Sunday, April 27, 2025

Review of "Everything Is Tuberculosis: The History and Persistence of Our Deadliest Infection" by John Green

 

 



Author John Green.

John Green is an American author and YouTuber who's perhaps best known for writing the young adult novel, 'The Fault In Our Stars'. Green is also an activist for better health care, especially for victims of tuberculosis.

In 2019, John Green and his wife Sarah - who work with 'Partners in Health' - were in Sierra Leone to learn about healthcare facilities.



At Lakka Government Hospital, which treats tuberculosis (TB) patients, John met an unusually small 17-year-old boy named Henry Reider - a congenial fellow who showed John around the facility. Green writes, "Everyone seemed to know Henry, and everyone stopped their work to say hello and rub his head or squeeze his hand....I believed him to be the son of a staff member."


Lakka Government Hospital near Freetown, Sierra Leone.


Henry Reider (17-years-old).

When Green asked the hospital's Dr. Micheal about Henry, he learned the boy was a TB patient, and he was so small because he'd grown up malnourished, and TB further emaciated his body. Dr. Micheal said Henry was being treated, but the antibiotics weren't working well enough.

Later, Green asked Henry about his treatment, and the boy said he swallowed pills every day and got injections that burned like fire under his skin. Henry also mentioned side effects, which for TB sufferers includes ravenous hunger that's almost unassuageable - a big problem when there's not enough to eat.

Henry's mother Isatu, who was struggling financially, visited Henry regularly and brought extra food when she could, but many TB patients aren't that lucky. Green notes, "Most of the patients at Lakka had no visitors. Many had been abandoned by their families: a tuberculosis case in the family was a tremendous mark of shame".

'
Many tuberculosis patients in Africa are abandoned by their families.

Meeting Henry lit a fire under Green, and the author became a warrior for adequate universal healthcare for TB patients. In this book, Green relates Henry's story, intertwined with the saga of tuberculosis through the ages.

TB is a contagious disease caused by a bacterium called Mycobacterium tuberculosis, which can be spread in the water droplets of a cough or sneeze.


Mycobacterium tuberculosis.


Tuberculosis is contagious, and is spread by coughs and sneezes.

The Mycobacterium tuberculosis germ has an unusually fatty, thick cell wall that makes it a formidable enemy to the immune system. In active cases, the body - especially the lungs - are slowly overwhelmed by infection, eventually leading to death.


Mycobacterium tuberculosis organisms can destroy the lungs

Tuberculosis is one of the worst scourges of humankind. In the last two centuries, TB caused over a billion human deaths, and is estimated to have killed around 14% of people who've ever lived. In 2023, TB killed 1,250,000 people, which is shameful for a curable illness.




Deaths from tuberculosis per 100,000 people

Green discusses the history of tuberculosis, which was once called consumption. Consumption was thought to be an illness of intelligent/creative (mostly White) people, with patients including Stephen Crane, Frédéric Chopin, Thomas Wolfe, Henry VIII of England, Paul Laurence Dunbar, Eleanor Roosevelt, Lin Huiyin, Simón Bolívar, Franz Kafka, Louis XIII of France, John Keats, Sultan Mahmud II, and all three Brontë sisters. During the heyday of TB, many people went to sanitoriums for 'rest cures.'


Tuberculosis sanatorium in Switzerland


Patients in a tuberculosis sanitorium

The 'White Plague' notion led to the racialization of TB. "As late as 1880, White American physicians insisted that consumption did not occur among Black Americans, who, it was claimed, lacked the intellectual superiority and calm temperament to be affected by the White Plague." Of course, this resulted in lack of treatment for Black TB victims.

This changed in 1882, when Mycobacterium tuberculosis was identified as the cause of TB, and the organism was found in Black sufferers. Now doctors claimed that African-Americans were disproportionately dying of TB because of factors related to race, like smaller chest capacity and increased rate of respiration. This is nonsense, and Green notes that Black Americans were more susceptible to TB because of poverty, crowded housing, bad sanitation, bad working conditions, long hours, poor food, and malnutrition.


In the early 20th century, Black families often had poor living conditions

Healthcare discrimination is also seen in many immigrant communities, and the bias extends to Indigenous people and to third world countries around the globe. Green observes, "This bias against marginalized people and the healthcare workers directly serving them has proven to be one of the great facilitators of tuberculosis over the last century".

Researchers sought an effective TB treatment for decades, and the antibiotic streptomycin proved useful in the 1940s. By the mid-1950s, scientists developed the more effective RIPE cocktail, a combination of four antibiotics - Rifampin, Isoniazid, Pyrazinamide, and Ethambutol. The antibiotic pills must be taken every day for up to 9 months, and more advanced treatments may be supplemented by injections.



Green writes, "By the late 1950s, the illness was broadly curable....but even as TB became curable, the cure often did not reach the places that needed it most." Rates of TB dropped dramatically in rich countries, "But in dozens of countries, treatment either wasn't available or reached patients only sporadically. From India to Bolivia to Cambodia to Ethiopia to the 'Global South' in general, low and middle income nations continued to have TB death rates higher than those seen in the U.S. before the antibiotic era". Green sums it up as: the disease is where the cure is not, and the cure is where the disease is not.

To exacerbate the situation, many patients don't take their medicine every day, or stop before the regimen is complete. Sufferers may then develop antibiotic-resistant tuberculosis, which is much worse.....and which requires more powerful, expensive, and unpleasant medication. This happened to Henry Reider, in part because Henry's father interrupted the treatment when Henry was young, in the belief that the boy could be cured by a traditional faith healer.


Tuberculosis medicine can be daunting

Green devotes a good portion of the book to the issue of treatments available (or not) for TB. Part of the problem in poor countries is the high cost of the antibiotics, and the unwillingness of pharmaceutical companies to reduce their profit margins. Global health organizations are working hard to distribute the medications around the world, and there's been significant (but not enough) progress.

Henry's tale, peppered through the narrative, provides a sympathetic and relatable picture of one boy's struggle to survive. Henry often felt his death was imminent, and he found himself crying and too sad to leave his room. Henry worried about his mother Isatu, who loved him so deeply and would miss him so much. Henry wanted to finish school, have friends, write poems, and have a happy life.

Since this isn't a mystery novel, I won't keep you in suspense. Henry got better, and though he still has challenges, Henry earned admittance to the University of Sierra Leone, lives with his mother in Freetown, and is a YouTuber and TB activist.






Henry Reider

Addendum: With the advent of the Trump administration in 2025, the U.S. contribution to health care organizations has been slashed. "President Donald Trump's administration has moved to fire nearly all USAID staff, as billionaire Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency has slashed funding and dismissed contractors across the federal bureaucracy in what it calls an attack on wasteful spending."

Because of this, there are fears about an increase in TB globally, and an influx of patients with antibiotic-resistant TB coming to the United States. Hopefully, there will be a reversal in this policy, and aid will be restored.

Rating: 4 stars

Saturday, April 26, 2025

Review of "The Disappearance: A Speculative Dystopian Novel" by Philip Wylie

 


This book, published in 1951, speculates about the consequences of a monumental life-changing event.

As the story opens, World War II recently ended, the cold war is causing tension between the U.S. and Russia, and Americans are getting on with their lives.



Dr. William Gaunt, Ph.D. is a highly respected philosopher living in Miami, Florida with his wife, Dr. Paula Gaunt.





Paula has an M.A and a Ph.D. in ancient and modern languages: Sanskrit, Latin, Greek, Russian, and a bit of Chinese. William was pleased and proud, but perhaps slightly patronizing, when Paula continued to study in the early years of their marriage, expecting her to be a homemaker and mother. Nevertheless, William gladly makes use of Paula's talent to critique his lectures and papers.



William exemplifies the patronizing attitude men have towards women in the mid-20th century, no matter how accomplished the females are. The Gaunts' daughter Edwinna tells it as it is when she rails at her mother: Phooie! Twenty years of hard studying to learn a lot of things you've never used. Twenty-seven years of being dad's housekeeper and errand boy. All you do is write grocery lists in plain English and add drugstore bills and count dirty clothes.



That's all about to change. On February 14, 1950, the world splits into (what I'll call) two dimensions. In one dimension all the human females disappear, leaving only men.



In the alternate dimension, all the human males disappear, leaving only women.



This happens instantaneously, so in the women's world, planes are suddenly pilotless, trains are abruptly without engineers, delivery trucks lose their drivers, and so on. And women pregnant with boys suddenly find the mounds of their abdomens relaxed, caved in, all evidence of pregnancy vanished.



In the men's world, wives, mothers, daughters, housekeepers, etc. abruptly vanish. Food is left on the stove to burn; nurses disappear from patients' bedsides; frightened little boys wail for their mommies; etc.



In the first moments after the split, there are crashes and chaos in the women's world;



and bewilderment and fright in the men's world. No one can fathom, much less believe, what happened.



In the men's realm, William Gaunt speculates this might be mass hypnosis or universal schizophrenia.



In the women's realm, Paula Gaunt immediately has to deal with a flaming power pole felled by a car crash. And in both domains, America and Russia point fingers at each other.



Once the confusion subsides, and both genders realize they're now on their own, the men and women start to deal with the bizarre situation. On the men's side, Russia and the U.S embark on a short-lived nuclear war, then make peace.



On the women's side, by contrast, American and Russian women arrange a détente and work together.



In the men's realm, the president of the U.S. summons a 'Committee of Savants' to Washington for discussion and investigation, and Dr. Gaunt heads one of the committees. Since the men's domain is chock full of scientists and researchers, they try to find a scientific explanation for what happened, with hopes of finding a solution.

In his committee reports, Dr. Gaunt philosophizes endlessly about Adam and Eve; men and women; right and wrong; etc. and it's clear author Philip Wylie is using Gaunt as a mouthpiece for his own views. (This frequent cogitating gets old fast.)



In the women's realm, the wives of vanished politicians try to form a government of sorts, but get caught up in discussions of a suitable uniform for members - which should be chic, to keep up morale.



"The secretary of state, twice listed amongst America's ten best-dressed women, had had the forethought to invite to the congress her world-famed couturier, Elsie Bazzmalk." (Talk about a cliché, but the book needs some comic relief. LOL).

Homosexual activity increases in both dimensions, and as might be expected, the men's world (at least in the U.S.) manufactures sex dolls. This gives author Philip Wylie an opening to speculate about men and women and marriage.



When Gaunt sees a store selling sex dolls, he ponders: "To many men, a wife was little more than such an object as these dolls. Men of that sort were allured by the externals....They married not a personality - a mind, a cultural entity, a bundle of genes, ideas, or a soul - but a blue-eyed blonde with a good figure....Their 'love' was confined to using her as an erotic toy.....His [real life] chosen mate would age....child-bearing, child-rearing, domestic duties, and perhaps a job (along with the years) would gradually destroy in his mate every vestige for the reason he had once discovered for marrying her." Of course, these men might ditch their wives for young women.



As for the women, Gaunt thinks, "Often too, such a wife's not unnatural opinion that she was more than mechanical lust-putty led her to resentment." So, "both she and her miserable husband became embodiments of a general resentment - against each other, life, and the wide world."



Unfortunately for the female world, no women have run factories, power plants, homesteads, mines, pharmaceutical companies, hospitals, and so on, and things are very tough for them. Paula Gaunt becomes the head of various committees, and she's instrumental in organizing small farms, fire departments (such as they are), police departments (such as they are), delivery services, health care, hunting parties, and other necessities.





Nevertheless, the women's world reverts to something between being hunter-gatherers and primitive farmers, as in prehistoric times. There are nurses, but very few doctors, and - once the medicine runs out - disease runs rampant. Moreover, most industries soon revert to rust and ruins.



The men's side does much better with technology, but the men's homes become messy and untended; their clothing gets slovenly and dirty; they lose their appetites; they feel sad and depressed; and so on.





Both men's and women's worlds attempt parthenogenesis (asexual reproduction) to produce babies, but aren't successful. And both worlds experience violence, looting, murder, and havoc of all kinds.

The separation goes on year after year......and that's all I'll say.

I'd like to think an experience like this would teach both genders a lesson: men to respect and value women as more than wives, mothers, and helpmates; and women to assert themselves and insist on self-fulfillment on their own terms. I'm not sure if this happens in 'The Disappearance', but kudos to author Philip Wylie for (at least) understanding the issues.


Author Philip Wylie

I've seen reviews criticizing the book's homophobic and racist overtones, and though this is grating, I don't think it's unusual for the 1950s. It would be interesting to see the 'disappearance' premise addressed in current times, when women (at least in the Western world) have diverse careers; same-sex marriage hardly turns heads; and cloning babies is a real possibility.



The book is worth reading just for the speculative (though not completely unheard of) premise. Recommended to fans of dystopian novels.

 Rating: 4 stars