Friday, June 26, 2026

Review of "The Calamity Club: A Novel" by Kathryn Stockett

 


This book is set in 1933 Mississippi, when the Great Depression is devastating the country. The hardship caused by the economic collapse - as well as sexism, racism, homophobia, and eugenics - is seen through the eyes of the novel's two narrators: 24-year-old Birdie Calhoun and 11-year-old Meg Lafleur.

Birdie Calhoun, her Mama, and her Meemaw live on a farm in Footely, in the Mississippi Delta. The Calhoun women are struggling after a run of bad luck. Papa died from a heart attack; Meemaw broke her hip; the water pipes broke; and the truck gave up the ghost.



Birdie works as a bookkeeper at Footely Farm & Mercantile, but she's paid much less than the men working there, and the Calhoun women can't pay their property taxes. In danger of losing their home and farm, Birdie is sent to Oxford, Mississippi to ask her younger sister Frances for a loan.



Frances left the Footely farm in her late teens, went to finishing school in Memphis, and married WAY UP.



When Birdie gets to Oxford, she finds Frances and her husband Rory Tartt living with Rory's widowed mother, Mrs. Tartt.



The Tartts reside in an elegant mansion called Idlewilde, and Frances brags to Birdie, "The Tartts are upper-class people with stature. And they’ve been places, to Europe and Africa. Rory’s daddy was a very well-known businessman. He started one of the biggest banks in Oxford.”



Rory works for the bank his father founded, and travels around the south to visit clients;



and Frances volunteers at the Lafayette County Orphan Asylum for Girls, nicknamed the Orphan, which is run by Chairlady Garnett Pittman.



Frances isn't being altruistic, she's social-climbing. By kissing up to Garnett Pittman, Frances hopes to make inroads into Oxford high society. To gain brownie points with Garnett, Frances even volunteers Birdie's temporary services as a bookkeeper/accountant, to straighten out the orphanage’s financial records before an upcoming inspection.



Unfortunately for the orphans, Chairlady Garnett Pittman is a self-righteous, mean-spirited shrew. Rather than viewing the orphans as unlucky youngsters who need love and protection, Garnett considers them burdens and moral failures who need to be indoctrinated. Garnett views most things as sinful, and is running for President of the Anti-Vice League.



In any event, Garnett accepts Birdie's bookkeeping services, and shows her to the Orphan's shabby accounting office, which has moldy walls, stale air, and boarded-up windows. There Birdie meets 11-year-old Meg Lafleur. Garnett expelled Meg from the orphanage school, and makes the girl sit in the stuffy accounting office all day every day.



Meg is even obliged to eat her sparse meals in the office, away from the other girls. If Meg isn't adopted by age 12, she'll be sent to work at a canning factory, and the Orphan will get remuneration for Meg's labor.



Meg's story goes as follows: She was raised by a single mother called Charlie who cleaned houses. They were poor, but got by, and Charlie sang to Meg; told her stories; took her to the grocery store; let her browse in the five-and-ten; checked out books from the library; and did everything a loving mom does.



Then, when Meg was nine, Charlie went shopping right before Christmas, and didn't come back. Meg waited anxiously, had a few HORRIBLE days, and ended up in the orphanage under the 'care' of Garnett Pittman, who hates her. Meg keeps wishing and daydreaming her mother will come back.

While Birdie works on the Orphan's books, she and Meg spend time together in the accounting office. Birdie becomes fond of the girl, who's bright, artistic, well-read, and well-spoken. Birdie also notes Garnett's animosity toward the child.



Birdie takes it upon herself to pull the boards off the windows of the accounting office, clean the room, and paint the walls - and Meg helps. Going forward, Birdie maintains an interest in Meg, and vows to help her as best she can.



Back at the Tartts' Idlewilde mansion, Birdie is diffident, but finally tells Frances about the dire circumstances at Footely. Birdie reminds Frances that the Calhouns are her family as well, and asks for a loan of $250. Frances hems and haws and finally says, “I’ll figure out how to ask Rory. He’s just—he’s real sensitive about money right now.”



Frances is unaware that the Tartts will soon be bankrupt themselves, and in danger of having their mansion confiscated. The Tartts' lives are about to change drastically.

*****

I'll have to be circumspect now, to avoid spoilers. Here are a few highlights:

ᯓ➤ After being gone for two years, Meg's mother Charlie - shabby and distraught - comes to the orphanage, desperate to see her daughter. Luckily, Charlie encounters Birdie instead of Garnett, and tells her sad story. Charlie was arrested on the night she disappeared, sent to prison, deemed feebleminded, and sterilized. All this was engineered by Garnett Pittman, who's an awful woman. In any case, Charlie wants Meg back, but the situation is VERY complicated.



ᯓ➤ Frances's husband Rory Tartt has been keeping secrets, and big trouble ensues.

ᯓ➤ For romance fans, there are sparks for Birdie.

ᯓ➤ A gay character is described as having 'caught the homosexuality disease' and is sent away to 'get cured.'

ᯓ➤ A character who's 'passing for white' is violating Mississippi's miscegenation laws, which are strictly enforced in towns like Oxford.

*****

Midway through the novel, it's clear everyone needs money. Birdie needs funds to pay the property taxes on the family farm in the Mississippi Delta; the Tartts need cash to save their estate; and Charlie needs money to try to get Meg back.

So while the Tartts are absent from Oxford, and WITHOUT THEIR KNOWLEDGE, Birdie and Charlie cook up a scheme to use the Tartt property to run a temporary dancing school (wink wink) with female 'dancing teachers' (escorts) who take the 'dancing students' inside after a swing dance or two.



This enterprise takes up a large portion of the novel, and is the reason people say the story is too long (it is). There's a secondary plotline about a millionaire family that has troubles of it own and a tragic occurrence, but nuff said about that.



The book bogs down in places, but I rooted for Birdie, Charlie, and their friends as they schemed to solve their financial problems. I found the 'dance school' enterprise clever and ambitious, but it's unlikely to work in real life. In towns like Oxford, Mississippi, where everyone gossips - especially about people like the Tartts - the 'dance school' could NEVER be kept under the radar.



I enjoyed getting to know Birdie, Meg, Charlie and the other characters - even the ones you love to hate. Meg is an especially intriguing protagonist. She's courageous about her 'imprisonment' in the accounting office; draws clever portraits; lies like a politician (for a good cause); reads people like a psychologist; is kind and caring; and loves books, buttery biscuits, and chocolate desserts (as do I).



Overall, the novel seems to be a faithful representation of Mississippi in the 1930s and beyond, and it's a good story. Recommended.

I had the digital book and the audiobook, narrated by Jenna Lamia and January LaVoy, who do a great job with the voices of Birdie and Meg.

Rating: 4 stars

No comments:

Post a Comment