Wednesday, August 26, 2026

Review of "The Dying Light: A Detective Matthew Venn Mystery" by Ann Cleeves

 

 

In this 4th book in the 'Two Rivers' series, Detective Inspector Matthew Venn investigates the deaths of two teenage girls. The book can be read as a standalone.

*****

It's summer in North Devon, and residents and tourists are looking forward to MillsFest, a two-day music festival that features local bands and sells beer and alcohol.



A couple of attendees will be seventeen-year-olds from London: brunette Hannah Armstrong and blonde Lottie Cauldwell.



The girls just completed their A-Levels, and drove to Millscombe to spend a few days at Tide House - a vacation home owned by Hannah's family.



The morning after the festival, Detective Inspector Matthew Venn gets a call from Detective Sergeant Jen Rafferty, the duty detective. Jen reports, 'We have a body and a missing young woman at a fancy holiday home out at Millscombe. The owner is a politician called Paul Armstrong, who turned up this morning with his wife and two young sons. Armstrong's daughter and her friend arrived Friday morning. The Armstrongs found the friend drowned in the pool and the daughter disappeared."



Matthew meets Jen in Millscombe, a tiny hamlet that features a pub called the Fisherman's Arms, the Brennan farm, and a few scattered houses, including Tide House. Paul Armstrong explains they found Lottie in the pool, and he and his wife Cath fear their daughter Hannah was kidnapped, perhaps for ransom or political reasons.



Things are even more dire than that because Hannah's body is found in the woods below Tide House. This sets off a murder investigation led by DI Venn, whose team includes DS Jen Rafferty and Detective Constable Ross May.



Interviews with family members reveal that Lottie and Hannah met at a private school in London and became friends. The detectives also learn Hannah had a boyfriend in Millscombe, a lad named Jake Brennan whose parents own the Brennan farm - a working farm that hosts the music festival and rents out glamping pods.



When the investigators trace Lottie and Hannah's activities in Millscombe, they learn the underage girls tried to buy alcoholic drinks at the Fisherman's Arms and were refused. Lottie made a big fuss and antagonized the owner. Then, over the weekend, Lottie engaged in other mischievous behavior.



The detectives also learn that an American couple renting one of the glamping pods on the Brennan farm, Geoff and Karen Kinzalow, have a daughter Elizabeth who went to school with Lottie and Hannah.



The murder investigation moves along very slowly since the detectives speak to the same people again and again; key persons make themselves unavailable; and almost everyone either lies or withholds information.

In the meantime, Matthew Venn and his husband Jonathan Church have a personal concern. Jonathan is an adoptee who's found his birth mother, and they've arranged a meeting via email. Both Jonathan and Matthew are apprehensive about the reunion and its possible aftermath.



The 'Two Rivers' novels are character studies as well as mysteries, and it's interesting to see the changes in the protagonists' lives.

DI Matthew Venn was brought up in a religious sect called the Barum Brethen, which shunned him when he lost his faith, and estranged him from his parents. Matthew's father died, but he's now partly reconciled with his mother, who knows Matthew is gay, and that his husband Jonathan is part of his life.



DS Jen Rafferty is a single mother who was struggling to raise teenagers Ella and Ben, do her job, and have time to party. Ella is now off to university; Ben is in the sixth form; and Jen doesn't party so much as enjoy an evening glass of wine with her musician neighbor.



DC Ross May had inflated ideas about his abilities, and chafed at being assigned (what he considered) boring, mundane police duties. Ross has now learned to interview witnesses and no longer complains about routine assignments. Ross might have matured because of potential fatherhood, since he and his wife Mel are trying to have a baby.



The story moseys along to a conclusion that will get the best of most armchair detectives. I enjoyed the novel, but became irritated with the detectives' snide thoughts about 'rich people', 'educated people', 'successful people', 'well-spoken people' and so on. What's wrong with being

 smart and doing well?

I had a digital copy of the novel as well as the audiobook, narrated by Jack Holden, who does a fine job.

Thanks to Netgalley, Ann Cleeves, Macmillan Audio and Minotaur for ARCs of the book.

Rating: 3 stars 

No comments:

Post a Comment