Tuesday, November 11, 2025

Review of "Before We Forget Kindness: Before The Coffee Gets Cold #5" by Toshikazu Kawaguchi

  


In this 5th book in the 'Before The Coffee Gets Cold' series, four individuals 'time travel' to reduce the burden on their hearts. The book can be read as a standalone.

On a side street in Tokyo there's a little coffee shop called Funiculi Funicula that has a very unusual feature.



The café allows people to travel back, or on rare occasions, forward in time. There are rigid rules for time travelers, however, as follows:

- Whatever you do, you CANNOT change the present or the future.

- You can only interact with people who have visited Funiculi Funicula.

- You must sit in one specific chair in the café to time travel, and you can't leave the chair for any reason. The catch is, a ghost - in the form of a woman reading a book - occupies the chair and only leaves once a day to go to the toilet.



- A cup of coffee starts the journey, and you MUST return to the present before the coffee gets cold.



As the book unfolds, four people take advantage of the time travel feature - each one for their own reasons.

Patrons who visit Funiculi Funicula, either for refreshments or for time travel, are likely to meet the following people:

☕︎ Nagare Tokita - the owner of the café; he's over six feet tall and wears a white cook's uniform.



☕︎ Kazu - Nagare's cousin, who works as a waitress in the café; she pours the coffee for the time travelers.



☕︎ Fumiko Kiokawa - a university graduate who knows six languages; she also visits the café every day after work.



*****

In each of the four vignettes in this book, a person has something on their mind, and feels compelled to make amends.

💥 Seven year old Yuki Kiriyama visits Funiculi Funicula, and asks if it's true he can go back in time. Kazu tells him yes, and Yuki explains he wants to go back to the previous Christmas.



On that day, Yuki's mother and father took him to Disneyworld, then to Funiculi Funicula for Christmas cake. While there, Yuki's parents told him they were separating, and Yuki burst into tears.



Yuki now realizes his folks are happier apart, and he wants to go back and NOT cry when he hears the (to him) sad news.

*****

💥Megumi Sakura and her husband Riuji were expecting a baby, and elected to wait until the child was born to name it.



Shortly before Megumi's due date, Riuji was killed in an altercation. Soon afterwards, Megumi had a little girl, and she has one more day to name the baby.



Megumi wants to go back in time WITH the infant, so Riuji can see his child and give her a name. This is a tricky proposition, though, because as soon as Riuji sees Megumi with the baby, he'll realize his fate.

*****

💥 Fumio Mochizuki regrets forbidding his daughter Yoko to marry her boyfriend years ago. Fumio went so far as to say Yoko could never return home if she wed this man.



💥Yoko, a strong-minded girl, eloped and had a son named Mitsuru. However, Yoko's marriage ended soon afterwards.



Yoko's life has been difficult since then, and she needs help, but she's too ashamed to approach her father.

This vignette is a bit complicated, but father and daughter have a rapprochement when Yoko travels to the past, and Fumio travels to the future.

*****

Tsumugi Ito and her friend Ayame Matsubara bonded as young schoolgirls, over their love of history and castles. The girls even developed the habit of speaking in Samurai dialect, and they became the best of friends.



In high school, however, Tsumugi became jealous when a boy she liked expressed interest in Ayame.



Tsumugi became so resentful, she broke off her friendship with Ayame and avoided her. It's now years later, and Tsumugi learns things that make her regret her actions. Time travel and Valentine chocolates help ease Tsumugi's mind.



*****

It's heartening to see the characters redress wrongs and/or ease their minds. That said, this is my least favorite of the 'Funiculi Funicula' books because I didn't like some of the protagonists.



💥 Yuki's parents were divorcing, in part, because they couldn't agree on their domestic arrangements. I found Yuki's father especially irritating because he wanted to dictate how things were done at home, but used his work as an excuse to avoid helping with child-rearing or domestic chores.

💥I got annoyed with Koko, who eloped, because she had no common sense about men. Koko did extremely foolish things, not once, but twice.

💥As for Tsumugi, her behavior was terribly immature. Tsumugi rejected her BEST friend Ayame because a boy liked Ayame. How silly is that?

That said, I'd encourage fans of the series to read the novel, but for newbies, I'd say start with book one.

Rating: 3 stars 

No comments:

Post a Comment