Tuesday, November 4, 2025

Review of "The Girl in the Green Dress: A Mystery Featuring Zelda Fitzgerald" by Mariah Fredericks


This book is loosely based on real life events. In 1950, journalist Morris Markey was found dead in his home, with a bullet wound in his head. There was an open coroner's verdict: suicide or accident.





That same year, Markey wrote a story about playboy George Elwell, who also died from a bullet wound in his head. This novel is a fictional account of Joseph Elwell's demise in 1920.

*****

Morris Markey, born in Virginia in 1899, is enticed by a WWI recruitment parade, and joins the Red Cross in 1918. Markey's job is to come out after the battle is finished, gather up what remains, and get it into an ambulance.



Unfortunately, Markey sees soldiers torn up and shrieking with pain, and the experience leaves him shell-shocked. Afterwards, in loud rowdy situations, Markey hears buzzing in his head and zones out.

After the war, Markey starts his journalism career in Atlanta before moving north. It's now 1920, and 21-year-old Markey is in New York, writing for the Daily News.



Markey can't help but compare himself to his acquaintance, F. Scott Fitzgerald, the writer everyone in New York is talking about.



For himself, Markey dreams of finding the right story, being there when the big thing happens, and telling people how it really is. This is about to occur. Late one night, Markey returns to his boarding house and sees his neighbor, Joseph Elwell, emerge from a yellow roadster with a beautiful red-head in a green and silver dress. Elwell nods to the journalist and enters his brownstone with the young lady.



Markey's heard that Elwell - a notorious womanizer - owns racehorses, plays cards, invests in the stockmarket, and teaches bridge to socialites - but only if they're pretty and only if they're married.



The next morning, Markey is woken by a woman shouting, "Help me, please, there has been a robbery, a man has been shot." The woman is Mrs. Larsen, Elwell's housekeeper, and Markey hurries across to Elwell's brownstone and offers to assist.



Markey sees Joseph Elwell slumped in the drawing room with a single bullet hole in his forehead. Rather than provide help, Markey takes the opportunity to snoop in all the rooms, expecting to find the woman in the green and silver dress, whom he thinks is the killer. There's no female - or anyone else - in the house, but Markey's happy to call in Elwell's death, scooping other reporters.



The police investigate Elwell's homicide, and Markey decides to join in, hoping to expose the culprit himself.



A matchbook from the Ritz-Carlton Hotel tells Elwell the playboy was socializing there the night before his murder. Markey learns Scott and Zelda Fitzgerald are staying at the Ritz-Carlton, and he calls on them to get entrée to the luxurious premises.





Markey observes that the Fitzgeralds had not just taken a suite at the Ritz; they had taken it over. Their living room was the size of his entire apartment, and after a party last night, "Small plates with remnants of sandwiches, bits of cheese, smears of chocolate and caviar sat abandoned on side tables, chairs, the floor, the top of the grand piano. Flutes and highballs were everywhere he looked. The ashtrays were full, and most of the plateware held cigarette stubs. Near the gramophone, a pile of records had been knocked over, sliding like playing cards across the carpet."



Markey tells the Fitzgeralds about Elwell's murder, and explains he's looking for the redhead in the green and silver dress. Zelda recalls seeing Elwell at a party in the hotel's Japanese garden, but the playboy wasn't with a girl in a green and silver dress. Elwell was with Viola Kraus, "the most beautiful girl in New York", who claims to be Elwell's fiancée.


Viola Kraus

Markey's suspicions now fall on Viola Kraus, and Zelda - who's ALWAYS up for wild adventures - decides to help Markey investigate Elwell's killing.



As an acquaintance of the Fitzgeralds, Markey gains admission to Elwells's regular haunts, like the Midnight Frolic at the New Amsterdam Theatre.....



......and the Studio Gentleman's Club on Park Avenue.



As Markey circulates in high society, he interviews Elwell's friends, acquaintances, and estranged wife Helen - who despises Elwell for refusing to support herself and their son.




Joseph Elwell's estranged wife Helen

Markey comes to suspect one person after another of killing the playboy, and most of the 'suspects' are women Elwell romanced and their jealous husbands or lovers. Nevertheless, other people are thrown into the mix as well.


Women scrutinized by Markey and the police

In the midst of all this, Markey relishes the opportunity to write article after article about Elwell's murder, galvanizing the public, who always love this kind of scandal.



Things get more complicated when Markey's upstairs neighbor, a nosybody called Arthur Griswold, is shot; and a bullet comes through Markey's window as well. In addition, Markey learns Elwell was a member of the American Protective League (APL), an organization formed during WWI. The APL identified suspected German sympathizers and worked against radicals, anarchists, anti-war activists, and left-wing labor and political organizations.



In the end, Markey identifies the killer (though Elwell's murder wasn't solved in real life.)

The most entertaining scenes in the book revolve around Scott and Zelda Fitzgerald, whose lives in the roaring twenties were public performances.



For instance, at the Midnight Frolic, Scott gets drunk and strips, ready to join the dancers on the stage; and Zelda climbs on the lion statue in front of the New York Public library. The couple also make themselves the center of attention at parties, drinking and relating one anecdote after another about their escapades.





In her Author's Note, Mariah Fredericks notes there's no record of Morris Markey ever meeting the Fitzgeralds, though they had friends in common. Still, Fredericks does a fine job combining fact and fiction in this engaging story.

Thanks to Netgalley, Mariah Fredericks, and Minotaur books for a copy of the book.

Rating: 4 stars

No comments:

Post a Comment