Monday, November 10, 2025

Review of "The Guardians: A Novel" by John Grisham

  

 Cullen Post was a 30-year-old public defender in Memphis when he had a nervous breakdown.



Post subsequently became an Episcopal minister, was introduced to prison ministry, and helped free Francois (Frankie) Tatum.





Frankie was an innocent Black man serving life for someone else's murder, and was finally freed after 14 years in the penitentiary.



At the age of 48, Post is now an Episcopal minister/lawyer working for the 'Guardian Ministries Innocence Project' in Savannah, Georgia.



The non-profit, whose mission is to exonerate the wrongly convicted, has a shoestring budget, and employs four people: Vicki, Mazy, Post, and free-lancer Frankie.





Post spends most of his time driving all over the south speaking to prisoners, interviewing witnesses, searching for new evidence, etc. Meanwhile Vicki and Mazy do computer research and file briefs, and Frankie is a shadow working under the radar, out of sight of the 'real perp(s).'

So far, Guardian Ministries has exonerated eight convicts, and is currently working to free five prisoners, two of whom are Duke Russell and Quincy Miller.



➤➤ Duke Russell, a White man, is on Alabama's death row, convicted of raping and killing Emily Broone 11 years ago.



Post believes the architect of Duke's wrongful conviction is a small-town prosecutor named Chad Falwright.



Falwright overlooked the last man seen with Emily, didn't test pubic hairs found on Emily's body, and used 'expert witnesses' who were later exposed as incompetent.

Post is trying to get the evidence re-examined, and Falwright - who views Drew's conviction as his biggest success - fights Post every step of the way.

*****

➤➤ Quincy Miller is in prison for murder, and Post believes his conviction was orchestrated by a conspiracy.



Twenty-two years ago, Quincy Miller was found guilty of murdering his divorce lawyer, Keith Russo, in Seabrook, Florida.



Keith Russo considered himself above divorce cases, and his shoddy legal work saddled Quincy - a young Black man with three children -with alimony and child support he couldn't afford. Quincy's salary was garnished, he lost his job, had to file for bankruptcy, got caught selling drugs, and went to jail for a year.

Later, when Keith Russo was found in his office, dead from a shotgun blast, Sheriff Bradley Pfitzner quickly arrived to take charge of the case, brushing aside the local police.



Keith's wife and law partner, Diana Russo, pointed to Quincy as a possible suspect. According to Diana, Quincy would come by the office, threaten the staff, and demand to see Keith. Diana also claimed Quincy called their home and made threats.



The murder weapon was never found, and Quincy's conviction relied on the following:

➜ The police confiscated Quincy's car, and Sheriff Pfitzner found a flashlight in the trunk. The flashlight allegedly had specks of blood that looked like backspatter from a shooting. The flashlight didn't make it to trial, but a 'blood spatter expert' studied a photo and testified.



➜ Quincy's ex-wife said he owned a flashlight and a shotgun, which Quincy denied.



➜ A drug addict named Carrie Holland claimed she saw a Black man running from the area, who appeared to be carrying a stick or something.



➜ A jailhouse snitch testified that Quincy admitted to killing Russo.



That was enough to get a guilty verdict in a White town with a jury that contained only one Black person.

Post believes Quincy was framed by Sheriff Pfitzner, who planted the flashlight and coerced/bribed the witnesses. Post theorizes that Pfitzer and Russo were in league with a drug cartel. Russo fell out with the cartel, who had him killed, and the sheriff covered it up. Pfitzner then put the blame on Quincy, who was a convenient scapegoat.

Post's theory is supported by the fact that his court appearances are being carefully observed by a shady lawyer in Florida and his criminal associate. An attempted murder proves the cartel is determined to stop Post's inquiries, and keep themselves out of the limelight.




The novel follows the employees of Guardian Ministries - Post and Frankie in the field, and Vicki and Mazy on their computers - as they work tirelessly to expose the truth and get their clients freed.

This is a very good story and excellent advocacy for The Innocence Project.

Highly recommended.

Note: John Grisham himself is an ardent supporter of innocence projects. He writes, "It is a real privilege to serve as a Board member and Ambassador for the Innocence Project, one of the leading litigation and advocacy organizations in the country. There are thousands of innocent people in prison. It is our responsibility to share their stories, advocate on their behalf, and fight to reform the unjust criminal legal system.”

 

 Rating: 4 stars 

No comments:

Post a Comment