Friday, November 7, 2025

Review of "Nightshade (Catalina #1): A Detective Stilwell Thriller" by Michael Connelly

 


Michael Connelly, prolific author of crime and thriller books, is well known for his protagonists Harry Bosch, Mickey Haller, and Renée Ballard. In this debut novel, Connelly introduces a new investigator, Detective Sergeant Stilwell.


*****

Detective Sergeant Stilwell was a homicide investigator for the LAPD before a departmental dust-up got him transferred to the Sheriff's Department on the Catalina Island substation - the penalty for troublesome Los Angeles cops.



Most arrests on the island are drunk-and-disorderlies; assaults; property crimes; and driving while impaired. Today though, Detective Stilwell is investigating the mutilation of a protected species. A buffalo was killed on the Catalina Island Bison Preserve, and its head was sawn off.



Stillwell suspects that Oscar "Baby Head" Terranova, who owns Island Mystery Tours, ordered the mutilation. Baby Head has been pushing the idea of alien activity on Catalina, to drum up business for his tours.



Stilwell executes a search warrant on the premises of Island Mystery Tours, and confiscates a handsaw stained with blood. Stilwell also accuses an employee called Henry Gaston of mutilating the buffalo. Stilwell gives Gaston a few days to come in and make a deal - presumably implicating Baby Head.



Unknown to Stilwell, the dead buffalo is the tip of the iceberg of a criminal conspiracy that reaches into government circles, and this incident mushrooms to murder and abduction.



In the meantime, the body of a woman is found in the Catalina Island harbor. The deceased is in a sail bag, weighed down by an anchor, and has been in the water for days.



As a result the body is badly decomposed and difficult to identify. Murders are handled by the LAPD homicide unit on the mainland, and Stilwell reports the incident.



Unluckily for Stilwell, homicide Detective Rex Ahearn gets the case.



In Stilwell's opinion, Ahearn is lazy, cuts corners, and makes bad arrests. It was a disagreement with Ahearn that got Stilwell banished to Catalina Island, and there's bad blood between the two men.

When Ahearn and his partner Sampedro arrive on Catalina Island, there are nasty exchanges between Ahearn and Stilwell. Ahern scornfully calls Stilwell 'Stillborn.' And Stilwell returns the favor by calling Ahearn 'A-hole.'



After throwing his weight around, Ahearn arranges to take the body back to Los Angeles, and warns Stilwell to stay off the case.



Stilwell does no such thing. Instead he plunges right in to investigate. The first order of business is to identify the victim, and Stilwell has a stroke of luck. Charles Crane, the general manager of Catalina Island's Black Marlin Club (BMC), reports a theft. The exclusive BMC has an invitation-only membership of rich families, most of whom own yachts and live along the California coast.



Crane says a small black-jade sculpture of a marlin was stolen from the entry hallway of the BMC clubhouse.



Crane suspects the marlin was taken by a waitress named Leigh-Anne Moss, who was fired for inappropriate behavior, namely flirting with the male club members. Crane describes Leigh-Anne as having black hair with a purple streak, and Stilwell realizes this matches the corpse in the harbor.



Leigh-Anne's name gives Stilwell a starting point for his investigation, and he goes back and forth to the mainland to interview the victim's lovers, friends, acquaintances, and co-workers.





When Detective Ahearn finds out, he pitches a fit. But Stillwell's progress convinces the head of homicide, Captain Corum, to put Stilwell on the case with Ahearn and Sampedro.



In Stilwell's private life, he's dating Natasha (Tash) Dano, the assistant harbormaster on Catalina Island.



Tash gets interested in Leigh-Anne's murder, and helps Stilwell look up arrivals and departures of yachts - one of which may have been the murder scene.



Stilwell is an aggressive detective who skirts the rules, which irritates his boss, Captain Corum. Fortunately for Stilwell, he's clever and identifies the perp(s). The finale leaves some loose ends though, which will probably be addressed in future books.



This looks like the start of a good new series. Recommended to fans of mysteries and thrillers.

Rating: 3.5 stars

No comments:

Post a Comment