Wednesday, July 29, 2026

Review of "Miracle And Wonder: Conversations With Paul Simon" by Malcolm Gladwell and Bruce Headlam

  


This book by journalists Malcolm Gladwell and Bruce Headlam is a 'musical biography' of Paul Simon (b. 1941), available only as an audiobook. The book is narrated by Malcolm Gladwell, and contains interviews and conversations with Paul Simon along with additional material.


Malcolm Gladwell (left) and Bruce Headlam

Gladwell and Headlam visited Simon in various locations around the country, and conducted nine lengthy interviews. The conversations usually began with a song. The journalists would suggest one or Simon would, and Paul would talk about the song, sometimes sing a little bit of it; or they would play the original recording and Paul would break it down as they listened, "like a color commentator on a football broadcast." The trio spoke about Paul's "songwriting, his craft, an examination of the sources of his extraordinary creativity."

The audiobook includes Paul singing live and playing recorded music. The songs are then discussed in depth, including things like inspiration, lyrics, sound production, instrumentation, percussion, rhythm, notes, chords, and so on.

Simon has had a notably long career, from the time he was a teenager in Queens, New York to now, when Paul is in his eighties.


Paul Simon

Gladwell and Headlam call Simon a musical genius, and note that - unlike older performers who rely on their former hits - Simon constantly produces new material, and continues to collaborate with fellow artists.

One of Paul's early hits was 'The Boxer' (1969), sung with Art Garfunkel when they were a singing duo.



The song begins:

I am just a poor boy though my story's seldom told
I have squandered my resistance for a pocketful of mumbles

Such are promises, all lies and jest
Still a man hears what he wants to hear And disregards the rest, hmmm ....."

In the middle, the song has the refrain:

"La la la

Li la li
Li la li
Li la li
Li la li
Li la li

Li la li
Li la li
Li la li
Li la li
La, la, la, la, la, la, la

Simon explains, "I always intended to write lyrics for that section. I just couldn't think of what the chorus should be. So I was just singing La la li as a space holder....and I kept it. And it's so fortunate that that's what I did because when I sing that song anywhere, all around the world, people sing La la li."

That's just a snippet of the conversation about 'The Boxer', and Simon speaks about the song in much more depth.

Paul also discusses many of his other songs. A hit that garners much attention is 'Bridge Over Troubled Water' (1970), which was originally sung by Art Garfunkel.



The song quickly became a huge success. In the following years, 'Bridge Over Troubled Water' was covered by singers around the world; high school and college choirs sang it as a choral piece; and bands and orchestras played it. One of the first covers, a gospel version sung by Aretha Franklin, became a giant hit. The audiobook contains snippets of all these versions of the song.



Simon talks a great deal about the intricacies of composing his songs, referring to slapback, echoes, elements of music, keys, instruments, his musical memory, and incorporating sounds from other traditions. In that vein, Simon speaks about collaborations with other musicians. As examples:

🔴 Simon collaborated with Reverend Claude Jeeter, the famous falsetto singer of 'The Swan Silvertones.' Simon and Jeeter recorded the song 'Take Me to the Mardi Gras' (1973) in Muscle Shoals, Alabama, with a New Orleans Band.


Claude Jeeter



🔴 In another illustration, Simon liked South African music he heard on a record. So in 1986, during Apartheid, Simon flew to South Africa to record songs with musicians from the black township of Soweto.

South African bassist Bakithi Kumalo relates several anecdotes about the experience, starting with the time he was working as a mechanic, and his boss said Paul Simon was looking for him in town. Kumalo says,"I was so scared because....once I hear the English name....it's either something that has to do with jail, maybe somebody said I did something, I didn't know." When Bakithi learned Paul Simon was the musician who sang 'Mother and Child Reunion' (1972) he was thrilled, and he and other Black musicians recorded music with Paul in a studio.


Bakithi Kumalo

Afterwards, a few Black musicians were flown to New York, and Paul sent stretch limousines with white drivers to pick them up. Bakithi recalls, "When we came to JFK it was crazy.....They call us to get in the limo, but it's like whoa, because we expecting the bus or like a taxi, but this long car, we got so excited, and then the guy, the white guy comes in, and oh my god (lots of laughing) America is crazy man."

The collaboration between Simon and the South African musicians resulted in the album 'Graceland' (1986) which had Paul Simon's distinct exacting lyrics over jubilant African rhythms. The record won the Grammy for best album.



🔴 Later, Paul recorded a song in California, with Brazilian musician Milton Nascimento. Instead of just singing harmony, Paul sang phonetically in Portuguese. Paul then went to South America to work with Brazilian drummers, which led to the album 'The Rhythm of the Saints' (1990).


Milton Nascimento



🔴 Then in 2005, Simon teamed up with jazz icon Herbie Hancock to record Paul's song, 'I Do It For Your Love' (1975). Hancock recalls Paul was excited about a whole new approach to his song, and wanted to do it all in a minor key. Herbie was confounded until he thought of a way to do it by using one note as a pivot that everything would swivel around. Herbie laughs and says, "I chanted a lot for this record because it was a big big challenge. But I was very happy with the way it turned out. And I think Paul was too."


Herbie Hancock

Interviews with other musicians are scattered through the audiobook. For example:

🔴 British rock icon Sting talks about how much he likes Paul Simon's song 'America' (1968), because the words blur the line between lyrics and poetry. Sting observes, Paul's telling you a story. He deals with details: packs of cigarettes, Mrs. Wagner's pies, falling asleep on a Greyhound bus...and then the epic 'we walked off to look for America'....that's heartrending."


Sting

🔴 American singer-songwriter Roseanne Cash says she and her two-year-old grandson got teary-eyed listening to Paul Simon's song 'The Only Living Boy in New York' (1970) because it's beautifully and authentically anthemic.


Roseanne Cash

🔴 Record producer/sound engineer Roy Halee, who's collaborated with Paul for more than 60 years, talks about recording instruments; adding effects; and designing the sound and feel of Paul Simon records. Among other things, Halee says 'The Boxer' - which took over 100 hours to complete - is the greatest single ever made (he admits he's biased). The song required different locations, different microphones, different players, different parts, etc.


Roy Halee

For 'The Only Living Boy in New York' (1970), Halee put Simon and Garfunkel INSIDE an echo chamber. According to Halee, this resulted in a "a magical, magnificent, wonderful wonderful, full beautiful sound." Halee's interview is fun and informative.

🔴 Gospel artist producer and composer Aaron Lindsey explains how 'Bridge Over Troubled Water' became a beautiful gospel song. Lindsey says gospel music, like other genres, has almost a proprietary set of chord structures and movements. And Paul Simon, Art Garfunkel and Larry Knechtel (pianist) found a clever way to add one of those familiar movements to 'Bridge Over Troubled Water.' Then Aretha Franklin picked it up and made it a slam dunk gospel song.


Aaron Lindsey

🔴 American musician Jeff Tweedy said, if he was asked to cover a Paul Simon song, he would choose 'Rewrite' (2011) because he likes the guitar rhythms. Tweedy aspires to have a creative career like Paul, "who's aged into a songwriter who's still invigorated, still pushing himself to make something he hasn't made already."

\
Jeff Tweedy

🔴 Opera singer Renée Fleming, who sings Simon's song 'Love and Hard Times' (2011) on her Christmas album, admires Paul's vocal and artistic longevity. She says "we're lucky to have had him for this long, to have him continually thinking in a creative fruitful manner about what he wants to say to the world."


Renée Fleming

Throughout the book, Simon talks about his brilliant father Lou Simon, a gifted musician who went back to school in his fifties, to get a Ph.D. in linguistics. Lou's cancer diagnosis and imminent demise inspired several of Paul's songs.

Simon announced his retirement after the album 'Stranger to Stranger' (2016), but the retirement didn't stick. On January 15, 2019, the date Simon's father passed away in 1995, Paul had a prophetic dream. He recalls, "I dreamed that I was either working on a piece called seven psalms or I was supposed to go to work on a piece called seven psalms...And I thought okay, I'm supposed to make seven psalms. I don't know how to do it....but I guess instructions will follow."

Instructions DID follow, because the album 'Seven Psalms', was released in 2023. For the recording, Simon started from scratch: he picked up a guitar and wrote guitar pieces, and after a year words started to come, also from dreams. Gladwell observes, "The seven psalms are songs of a sort, but it's hard to listen to them individually. The album wants to be listened to all in one go." The theme is spiritual. The music acoustical. It's just Paul, his guitar, and subtle undercurrents of percussion. Simon talks about using his guitar as an entire orchestra in the album, and adding subtle bells and gongs.



The chorus of the first track of 'Seven Psalms' - called 'The Lord' - goes like this:

The Lord is my engineer
The Lord is the earth I ride on
The Lord is the face in the atmosphere
The path I slip and I slide on

In Gladwell's opinion, the most beautiful song on the album is the sixth psalm, called 'The Sacred Harp', that tells the story of a couple driving a truck through a thunderstorm, and picking up two hitchhikers, a woman and a child. Paul sings the psalm as a duet with his wife, singer-songwriter Edie Brickell.


Paul Simon and Edie Brickell singing 'The Sacred Harp' on the Steven Colbert Show

Paul Simon is still writing songs and performing, which is good news for his fans.

There's much more in the audiobook, which you don't want to miss if you're a Paul Simon fan. I liked the book, listened to it several times, and highly recommend it.

Thanks to Netgalley, Malcolm Gladwell, Bruce Headwell, and Pushkin Industries for an ARC of the book.

Rating: 5 stars 

No comments:

Post a Comment